The Development of Dandy Gilver

Dandy Gilver

What was the inspiration behind the creation of detective Dandy Gilver?

Posted on February 23, 2017 in Behind the Scenes
Tags: catriona mcpherson, dandy gilver

I was alone in my room . . .

It was back in 2001 that I first made the acquaintance of Dandelion Dahlia Gilver (née Leston) the detective heroine of what was going to be a bit of fun – a palate cleanser between serious writing projects – and is now a series of twelve novels.

I know what I did deliberately to conjure her, because I’ve still got the sheet of paper I made my notes on.

She was going to be upper-class, married, two sons at boarding school, and a house in Perthshire.

I had reasons for all those decisions, although I’ve regretted every one of them at some time or another.

She had to be upper-class because a middle-class woman, inside a straitjacket of sexual morality, wouldn’t have the freedom to go racketing about with a male sidekick. A working-class woman wouldn’t have the time after her twelve hour shift in the linoleum factory. Also, she needed a car if she was going to solve cases in rural Scotland in the 1920s. Wealth was essential.

She had to be married, an heir and a spare (ideally with a look of their father) safely born and past infanthood, because that was when upper-class female freedom kicked in. The girls were closely guarded until then.

I plonked her down in Perthshire for no better reason than it’s in the middle. I lived in Galloway at the time and, even with the A75, it’s still a long way from everywhere. I didn’t want every case to start with Dandy heaving herself up over the hills and across the moors to civilisation.

What I didn’t make up in any conscious way is her character. So where did she come from? It’s a mystery the equal of any that Dandy herself has ever solved.

The question I’m most often asked is ‘Is Dandy you?’

She’s not. Dandy Gilver – dark-haired, Victorian, aristocratic, English, mother, dog-lover and possessor of the stiffest of all upper lips – is incredibly-credibly not the blonde (born actual blonde and now ‘blonde’), child of the 60s, working-class, Scottish, childless, cat-loving over-reactor of some note, Catriona McPherson.

Funnily enough, it’s the cats and dogs that usually convince people.  Dandy is devoted to her badly-behaved Dalmatian, Bunty. Bunty is the member of the household who offers solace. She’s the one Dandy hugs most often. She’s probably Dandy’s favourite creature in the world.

I find dogs a bit heavy-going. All that crazed adoration every day! Those over-the-top greetings! I like the way a cat will open one eye and note your presence but be able to handle it. I even quite like how my cat, when I come home from a trip, lets me pat her then moves away, sits down and washes the place I’ve touched. And much as I love Rachel, she comes after a couple of dozen humans in my reckoning. (I’m going to have to step it up ever to achieve crazy-cat-ladyhood.)

It doesn’t matter that I don’t know where Dandy came from. At least, not now. But when I was writing the second book, it was terrifying. I had no idea how I had found her the first time, so I had no earthly clue what to do to bring her back again. I remember writing about half the first draft and then asking my husband to read it.

‘Never mind the plot,’ I said. ‘Or the style. Or even the spelling. Does this seem like the same person?’

He read a few pages and said: ‘Yes, of course. This is Dandy Gilver. I’m not so sure about you, though. Have you always been this big a space cadet?’

At least I was sure from the start about what Dandy looks like. As well as having dark hair, she’s tall and slightly heavy-hipped, with sallow skin and the shape of face that makes it hard to know where to put rouge.

If the second most common question I get about her – ‘What actress would play Dandy on telly?’ – ever becomes pressing, I’d have to dislodge that mental picture and install a new one. And it can be done: Colin Dexter managed a Geordie Sgt Lewis and Ann Cleeves has a red-headed Jimmy Perez. What a lovely problem to be faced with, anyway!


Dandy Gilver and a Most Misleading Habit is out today in paperback from all good bookshops and online retailers. 

More from the Crime Files blog


Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.